The Real Galactagogues: What Actually Helps Your Milk Supply (Hint: It's Not Lactation Cookies!)

McKayla Broadhurst, Utah Postpartum Doula & Nutrition Professional

How to Actually Boost Your Milk Supply

lactation bites utah postpartum meal prep

If you’re a new parent trying to boost your milk supply, chances are you’ve heard the hype about “magic” foods—lactation cookies, fennel seeds, brewer’s yeast, and more. While these galactagogues sound tempting (and who wouldn’t want cookies as a solution to boost your milk supply?), they unfortunately, aren’t the cure-all they’re made out to be.


But don’t worry. The truth is, boosting your milk supply comes down to a holistic approach - one that prioritizes effective milk removal, nourishment, and the right support. Let’s break down what really works to keep your breastfeeding journey thriving.

The Myth of Magic Foods


When you’re running on three hours of sleep, the idea that a cookie or a sprinkle of brewer’s yeast can save the day feels like a lifeline. And while galactagogues like oats, almonds, and certain herbs are packed with nutrients, they don’t address the main driver of milk production: effective milk removal.


That’s right—it’s not just about what you eat. It’s about how often and efficiently milk is being removed from your breasts. Without that piece, no amount of “magic” foods will truly work.

Why Galactagogues Alone Don’t Work


Galactagogues can support milk supply as part of a well-rounded diet, but they won’t solve underlying issues. The most common reason for low supply is infrequent or ineffective milk removal, which signals your body to slow down milk production.


So instead of leaning on a miracle cookie, shift your focus to strategies that directly impact milk production, like frequent feeding, proper latching, and a supportive network.

What Actually Works to Boost Milk Supply


Here’s what science—and experience—tell us really works to keep your milk flowing and your confidence growing:

1. Prioritize Nutrient-Rich Meals for Postpartum Recovery


Fueling your body with wholesome, nutrient-dense foods is a game-changer for milk production.


  • What to eat: Lean proteins, whole grains, fruits, veggies, and healthy fats like omega-3s. Foods rich in iron and calcium are especially supportive.
  • Why it works: Milk production demands energy, and nutrient-rich meals help your body meet those demands while supporting overall recovery.
  • How we help: At Bountiful Doulas, in addition to postpartum doulas co-owner McKayla is a Certified Postpartum Nutrition Professional. Let us help you plan and prepare meals that nourish both you and your milk supply.

2. Skin-to-Skin Contact: Simple, Sweet, and Effective


Few things are as powerful—and as simple—as skin-to-skin contact.


  • Why it works: This close bonding time triggers oxytocin, the “love hormone” that’s essential for milk letdown and bonding.
  • When to do it: Snuggle with your baby as often as you can, especially during feedings or after a bath.


3. Frequent Feeding and Pumping: The Milk Supply MVP


Frequent milk removal is the cornerstone of a thriving supply.


  • How often: Aim to feed or pump every 2-3 hours, even at night. This keeps your body’s milk production signals strong and steady.
  • Latching issues? Struggling with nursing or pumping? Our doulas are trained lactation educators who can guide you through latch techniques and pumping strategies to make feeding as effective as possible.


4. Build a Knowledgeable Support Network


Breastfeeding isn’t just about you and your baby—it’s about having a team that has your back.



  • Who to lean on: Your healthcare provider, an IBCLC, and even family and friends who can step in to handle chores or childcare.
  • Join a group: Local or online breastfeeding support groups are great for tips, encouragement, and solidarity. (If you’re in Davis, Weber, or Salt Lake County, Utah, we can connect you to some amazing groups!)


You’re Not the Problem—The System Is


If breastfeeding feels like a never ending battle, let’s be clear:
it’s not your fault. From limited maternity leave to a lack of workplace accommodations, systemic barriers often make breastfeeding harder than it needs to be. 


But here’s the good news: what you're doing matters, too. Every feeding, every pump session, and every attempt to reach out for support with a trusted IBCLC or Postpartum Doula is a win (and we see you!). Until the system catches up, know that you’re not alone—we’re here to help you navigate it.

Real Solutions for a Thriving Breastfeeding Journey


Boosting your milk supply isn’t about chasing the next miracle food. It’s about a holistic approach of things like nourishing meals, effective milk removal, quality time with your baby (that skin to skin magic!), and leaning on a support network. With the right strategies in place, your breastfeeding journey can thrive.

You Deserve Support


Whatever stage you’re in, remember: you don’t have to do this alone. At Bountiful Doulas, we’re here to provide lactation support, meal prep nourishing meals, and provide judgement free doula care tailored to your needs.


Contact us  today to learn more about how we can support your breastfeeding and postpartum journey. You’ve got this, and we’re here to help you thrive.

FAQs


Q: Do galactagogues really work?

A: They can support milk supply as part of a healthy diet but work best alongside consistent feeding or pumping.


Q: How often should I pump to increase supply?

A: Aim for every 2-3 hours, including at night, to keep up milk production signals.


Q: What should I eat to support milk production?

A: Focus on nutrient-dense foods like lean proteins, whole grains, and omega-3s, and don't forget the water to stay hydrated.


Q: Can stress affect my milk supply?

A: Yes, stress can lower milk production. Relaxation techniques, taking time for yourself, or leaning on support can help.


Q: Can I combine formula and breastfeeding?

A: Absolutely! Many parents use a mix of breastfeeding and formula feeding to meet their baby’s needs and maintain flexibility.

hospital newborn incubator in the nicu
By Bountiful Doulas March 28, 2025
The NICU journey is tough, but you’re not alone. Advocate for your baby, take care of yourself, and lean on support. When it’s time to go home, planning ahead helps. Your love and presence mean everything—you're doing an amazing job.
a burned out mother holding her newborn
By Bountiful Doulas March 26, 2025
Exhausted from sleepless nights and nonstop newborn care? A postpartum doula provides hands-on support—helping with baby care, feeding, sleep, and household tasks—so you can rest, recover, and adjust with confidence.
a woman supporting a new mother while she breastfeeds her baby
By Bountiful Doulas March 21, 2025
If family isn’t around or isn’t the support you expected, you can still build the village you need. A postpartum doula can provide hands-on help with newborn care, sleep, meals, and emotional support. Friends, parenting groups, and online communities can also make a difference.
By Bountiful Doulas March 19, 2025
Supporting a loved one through infertility can feel overwhelming, but small acts of kindness and understanding make a difference. Learn how to offer meaningful support, respect boundaries, and connect them with helpful resources.
a new mom holding her sleeping newborn baby
By Tiara Monson March 14, 2025
Newborn nights can be exhausting, but the right setup can make them smoother. Learn how to streamline feedings, create a soothing sleep space, and prioritize your rest. Plus, learn when to ask for help—because you don’t have to do it alone!
By McKayla Broadhurst March 7, 2025
Feeling overwhelmed as a new parent? You’re not alone! In this post, we’re sharing three key tips to help you navigate those early weeks with confidence—from baby care basics to setting realistic expectations.
By McKayla Broadhurst March 5, 2025
Overwhelmed in the newborn phase? A postpartum doula brings expert care, lactation support, and much-needed rest, helping you find balance and confidence. Let’s make postpartum easier—reach out today!
By McKayla Broadhurst February 18, 2025
Parenting twins or triplets is a wild, beautiful adventure—double (or triple!) the love and the challenges. We share real-life tips on managing feedings, getting rest, and accepting help. With the right support and a little humor, you can thrive as a family of multiples!
postpartum mom making a smoothie
By McKayla Broadhurst February 14, 2025
Nourishing yourself in postpartum doesn’t have to be overwhelming. From overnight oats to sheet pan meals, this guide offers quick, nutritious meal ideas to fuel your recovery—because you deserve more than coffee and crackers. Plus, learn how a postpartum doula can help take meal prep off your plate.
dad using baby carrier to clean
By McKayla Broadhurst February 12, 2025
Newborn life can feel like a whirlwind, but with the right tricks, you can make things easier (and get more sleep!). From game-changing swaddles to diaper blowout hacks, these 10 newborn care tips will help you navigate those early days like a pro.
More Posts
Share by: